Go Back
Report Abuse
Colony Coin Co
Colony Coin Co review
Colony Coin Co review

Description

Gold and Precious Metals Company Review

Colony Coin Co Review: Services, Pricing, and Alternatives

An independent profile, with our recommended alternative for readers comparing gold IRA companies.

HQ: Newton, Massachusetts · Bullion and coin buyers, Local dealers

Colony Coin Co is a coin and numismatic dealer based in Newton, Massachusetts. Google reviewers rate it 4.2 out of 5 across 36 reviews.

Colony Coin Co overview

Colony Coin Co is a coin and numismatic dealer based in Newton, Massachusetts. Google reviewers rate it 4.2 out of 5 across 36 reviews.

This directory lists 12 gold and coin dealers in Massachusetts. Check current pricing and buyback terms with the company directly before you trade.

Colony Coin Co at a glance

Location Newton, Massachusetts
Type Coin and numismatic dealer
Customer rating 4.2 out of 5 on Google, from 36 reviews
Phone (617) 244-1972

Colony Coin Co services

  • Coin and numismatic dealer

What to ask Colony Coin Co before you buy

Every firm answers these differently, and the answers are what separate them. We do not publish fee or pricing data for the companies in this directory, so take these to the company directly and get the answers in writing.

  • What is the total price including shipping and insurance?
  • What would you pay to buy this same item back from me today?
  • Is the metal shipped insured and tracked, and what happens if it arrives damaged?
  • What is the return window, and does it differ for graded coins?
  • For graded coins, which grading service certified them and what is the certification number?
  • How is payment taken, and does the price change between quote and settlement?

Colony Coin Co FAQs

Where is Colony Coin Co located?

Colony Coin Co is based in Newton, Massachusetts. Confirm current address and opening hours with the company before travelling to a location.

How do I contact Colony Coin Co?

Colony Coin Co lists the phone number (617) 244-1972. We publish contact details as we collected them, so check the company's own website for the current number before you call.

What does Colony Coin Co do?

Colony Coin Co is listed in this directory as a coin and numismatic dealer. We list 12 gold and coin dealers in Massachusetts, and this is one of them.

How is Colony Coin Co rated?

Google reviewers rate Colony Coin Co 4.2 out of 5 across 36 reviews. That is a third party rating we collected rather than a score of our own, and we do not rank the companies in this directory by it.

What should I check before buying gold or silver from any dealer?

Ask for the total price in writing including shipping and insurance, and ask what the dealer will pay to buy the same item back on the day you buy it. That gap is the real cost of the transaction. Confirm the return window, ask whether the metal ships insured and tracked, and for coins sold as graded, confirm which grading service certified them.

Recent Google reviews about Colony Coin Co

These are the most recent Colony Coin Co reviews published on Google in Newton. They are shown newest first, not filtered by rating, and they are the reviewers’ own words rather than our assessment.

  • ★★★★★

    Owner is pleasant and is very fair with prices.always felt I got a good deal.

    Google review, 2026-07-13

  • ★★★★★

    I really enjoyed dealing with Harvey. He struck me as very honest. A true professional who clearly loves his work.

    Google review, 2026-05-03

  • ★☆☆☆☆

    i have tried to business with this shop a couple of times , both on the phone and in person . Showed up with cpl thousand $ in my pocket ready to buy to be completely dismissed and misled on prices and availability . Never again

    Google review, 2026-03-09

Other gold and coin dealers in Massachusetts

Compare gold IRA companies

How to use this listing. This is an independent directory profile compiled from public sources, not financial advice and not an endorsement. We do not publish fees, minimums or returns for the companies we list, because we do not hold verified figures for them. Confirm every cost and term directly with the company in writing before you buy or move retirement funds.

Colony Coin Co alternatives

Comparing gold IRA companies? Here is how this company compares with our recommended gold and silver IRA company, and why we recommend Augusta Precious Metals.

Colony Coin Co Augusta Precious Metals (our pick)
Guidance model Varies by company Education-first, one on one
Account setup Often self-directed Custodian and depository coordinated for you
Best for One-time bullion buyers Retirement savers funding a gold IRA

Our editorial comparison, based on public information. We recommend Augusta Precious Metals.

  • Education-first onboarding through a one on one web conference before any account is opened.
  • Coordinates the self-directed custodian and the approved depository for you.
  • Transparent about pricing, with lifetime support from the same account team.

See why we recommend Augusta Precious Metals

There are no reviews yet.